FC: fall-criterion correction and re-scoring (registered: CRITERIA_FC.json, 2026-11-11)

Why

Every runner had inherited from the project’s first runner a stop “pelvis tilt > 0.35 rad or pelvis height < 0.5 m”, counted as a fall, with no documented source. On dev seeds 1300-1302 (lift motion + 50 N fore-aft push), the final controller hit the 0.35 rad stop 3/3 with both feet loaded and the DCM inside the support. With the stop at 0.6 rad the same runs recovered 3/3 without a step (pelvis peak 0.37 rad). The stop is not neutral between strategies: an in-place hold may lean the trunk, while a step keeps it upright.

Criterion

Procedure

Reproduction check (_rep, original stops)

Counts (manuscript experiments, registered seed ranges; fc_counts.json, fc_sens_paper.json)

Experiment n Old recovered FC recovered FC held
BUD2 216 191 191 88
BUDF 240 180 181 93
COST1 348 330 330 214
EST1 380 316 315 212
EST2 152 131 131 89
HFDB (B11, SME, R1i, DB) 320 248 249 22
HFFINAL 848 680 689 353
HFLAT 192 167 170 94
HFLAT3 208 178 184 123
LAT2 608 425 425 311
LN2D 204 180 181 97
MOTCI 144 129 132 101
MOTCI2 192 149 152 95
NZ1 240 188 184 116
NZ2 80 75 71 53

Decisions

Factorial steps (seeds 1090-1099, 80 runs per variant, steps until the fall)

Variant Old steps FC steps
B11 210 231
hold layer alone (SME) 186 198
IMU estimate alone (R1i) 219 244
both (DB) 141 159

The order is unchanged. Totals rose because failed runs now continue past 0.35 rad and step before falling.

Sensitivity (reported, not a decision)

Other threshold audits (offline, robust_holdability/estcmp3_results_*.json)

Manuscript

Touchdown-timeout diagnosis (2026-11-11, exploratory)

What the stop is

How the runs looked at the stop

Re-run with the timeout disabled